Season 3

Alyssa was born to be a monster collector. Her whole family watched scary movies together and enjoyed sharing anything and everything creepy, spooky and macabre. By the time she was a little girl, Alyssa was collecting monster memorabilia. As she shows us today, her most prized possessions are her female-centric monsters, like the Bride of Frankenstein and Queen of the Dark Forest Barbie due to their "girl power" independence, but she still treasures and is proud to show off some other creepy collectibles like Frankenstein, Dracula, the Creature and Godzilla. Joining us at Alyssa's haunted house is a toy shop owner and monster lover himself, expert Michael Tomaso, who'll evaluate Alyssa's monstrous collection and try not to frighten her with his terrifying trade offer.

There may be no one more enthusiastic and energetic about Creature from the Black Lagoon than Larry Strothe. A devoted collector ever since he was a kid, Larry's monster-sized collection features everything from a life-sized Creature to some Scary Monsters Magazine cover art. Larry's brought along his good buddy and Monster Party podcast sparring partner, Matt Weinhold to step up the fun. Joining Lisa today--much to our collector's delight, is our expert John Gilbert, AKA The Arizona Gill-man, who will appraise Larry's collection and then try to pull off a seemingly impossible trade that means a lot to both our collector and expert.

It's no secret that Danny Biederman knows his spy stuff. With more than 4,000 spy and espionage-related collectibles, Danny's obsession for all things spy began after seeing some spy shows and movies in the 1960s. His collection includes some of the most iconic items you can think of, like shoes and cigarette cases - or are they? - as well as some one-of-a kind-collectibles from the James Bond series, Get Smart, Man From U.N.C.L.E. and Mission Impossible to name a few. He even had his collection exhibited at CIA headquarters. Joining Lisa is our pop culture expert Mark Short, who'll appraise Danny's collection and see if he can convince him to make a spy-guy trade-a quintessential Get Smart gadget for one of Danny's more modern and recognizable collectibles.

Marcia Tysseling plunged into the movie props and costumes world as the owner of Star Wares on Main, a star-studded costume and prop resale shop catering to some of Hollywood's biggest names and production companies. After selling her business, Marcia held onto her favorite memorabilia from movies and television shows including Jurassic Park, The Shawshank Redemption, and Laverne and Shirley. Joined by expert Mark Short, our host, Lisa, explores Marcia's high-end collectibles and even dons costume pieces from Thelma and Louise. After valuing the well-curated collection, Mark Short proposes a trade that could have Marcia flying as high as a bird...or plane.

Our host, Lisa, steps back to the Stone Age with Dave Nimitz and his impressive collection of The Flintstones memorabilia. Dave's mother inspired him to begin collecting at a young age, and her support paid off with a floor-to-ceiling collection dedicated to America's favorite cave-family. From rare collectible figurines to a plush doll gifted to him by Joseph Barbera, the creator of The Flintstones, Dave's collection spans the globe. Our collector finds himself at a crossroads when toy expert Mark Huckabone offers to trade a breathtaking piece of original artwork for not one, but two rare boxed games. Will these two toy fanatics strike a deal?

There may be no bigger Brady Bunch expert than Wendy Winans. Collecting for almost 50 years, Wendy has all the usual items you'd expect such as photos, a lunchbox and a full set of trading cards. But not many Brady Bunch collectors can lay claim to needlepoint made by Alice, or a blueprint of the Brady house which, as Wendy tells Lisa, is not exactly accurate. Wendy's friend Marilyn - who's heard about the Bradys since they were in high-school together - is here, along with our expert and personal appraiser Kate Martin, who admits she's a pretty big fan of the show herself. After Kate appraises Wendy's entire collection, she'll see if Wendy is up for a big Brady trade.

Laurence Sheinman is bonkers about Bugs Bunny. For more than 35 years, Laurence and his wife Jessica have enjoyed huntin' rabbits together. Laurence's fabulous collection includes a Bugs bronze statue, roller skates, and a special blinged out jacket - not with Bugs' face on it, but some of our collector's other favorite Looney Tunes characters. Our expert and appraiser of personal property, Kate Martin, joins us today to appraise Laurence's collection, and then will try to make a deal with him-one of his beloved Bugs Bunny collectibles in return for a special Bugs Bunny treasure he will have a hard time refusing.

Inspired by his uncle, Nathan Lippe developed a unique passion for collecting antique advertising at a young age. Now fueled by the thrill of the hunt, Nathan scours the country for neon signs and saves them from destruction. Nathan has a well-curated collection of antique oil cans, tin signs, and neon signs. Nathan shares some of his favorites with host, Lisa Whelchel, from a charming Reddy Kilowatt neon sign to a prop sign used in the classic baseball film, Field of Dreams. Kate Martin, appraiser of personal property, tackles the high sticker prices on Nathan's collection and shocks Lisa with her appraisal of an Oz-themed oil can. Nathan specializes in collecting advertising for soda brand, Double Cola, but Kate brings along a collectible set of Coca Cola signs to persuade our collector into a trade.

"Who you gonna call" for Ghostbusters collectibles? Try Guinness World Record holder for Ghostbusters memorabilia, Robert O'Connor. With thousands of Ghostbusters collectibles, including the Stay-Puft Marshmallow Man and Ecto-Glow figures, Robert's love for the movie and its memorabilia doesn't stop at just collecting. He's even made his own ghost traps and proton packs that are often mistaken for the real thing. Joining Robert today is his friend and fellow Ghostbusters collector, Marty, who shares his fondness for Ghostbusters memorabilia. Kate Martin, our expert and appraiser of personal property, is here too, to appraise Robert's unbelievable collection and see if she can convince him to hand over one of his beloved Ghostbusters collectibles for something she knows Robert is definitely going to want.

After a childhood spent sneaking backstage at rock concerts, David Poley has amassed an enterprise-level collection of rock music memorabilia. Many of David's favorite items, including a stage-played Mötley Crüe guitar and a towel worn by Mick Jagger, were obtained through David's concert-going savvy. His passion for David Bowie infused his collection with a valuable stage-played guitar and an obscure concert prop. David's daughter, Alex, briefly joins us to share her memories of traveling the world to watch her father's favorite artists. As Lisa tours the collection, music expert and KISSTORIAN, DASHDOWN, works up an appraisal. Before DASHDOWN proposes a uniquely rare guitar to trade, Lisa shocks our collector with a shout out from one of the most influential rock artists of all time.

Dave Sinker combines his passions for performing standup comedy and collecting comedy memorabilia into The Comedy Shrine, a comedy club and museum that houses thousands of comedy-themed collectibles. This former Second City performer tracks down some of the rarest collectibles, from an early 1900s Charlie Chaplin mutoscope to immaculately kept wax figurines and a lunchbox worth over $2000. Dave celebrates comedians throughout the ages with a collection that appeals to all generations. Joining Lisa and Dave is Dave's son and general manager of The Comedy Shrine, Patrick, and expert and certified appraiser Judy Martin. Judy brings signed memorabilia from a famous comedy duo to trade, but our collector struggles to let go of a prized possession.

Leslie Livingood lives, breathes and collects Paddington Bears. Her lifelong obsession began at age 5, after she bought her first Paddington at a garage sale. Leslie began collecting the British bear and never stopped. She shows Lisa some of her favorites, which include a personalized Paddington Build-A-Bear, blue line sketches from the Paddington cartoon and a Paddington poster signed by Paddington author Michael Bond just days before he passed. Joining Leslie is her husband James who knew Leslie and Paddington were a package deal. Kate Martin, an appraiser of personal property will value Leslie's emotional and incredible Paddington collection and try making a trade with her, but it won't be anything Leslie ever expected.

Hooked on the music, the message, the props and its optimistic tone, Dave became enamored with Star Trek as a kid and never looked back. Since the 70's he's been an avid collector of not only screen used props like Tribbles or even the space panel button from Captain Kirk's chair, but he has also amassed some amazing replica items like the 3D chess set and Star Trek communicator that look as good as the real thing. Joining Dave today is his supportive wife Karen, who also likes Star Trek, just not as much as her husband. Movie props expert Mark Short will assess Dave's collection and then offer him a trade-his screen used Star Trek prop, for one of Dave's.

Allen Singleton's love of toy collecting began almost 40 years ago. Today, he and his wife, Diana, have turned this passion into a vintage toy franchise, Applejax Toys. Allen has been collecting G.I. Joes since the 1980s, and now he has a basement filled with over 100,000 G.I. Joe collectibles to prove it. Lisa and appraiser of personal property, Kate Martin, join the couple as Allen shares his favorite items and vast knowledge of the "Real American Hero". Allen's collection features pieces such as a rare "silent" comic book, a first edition G.I. Joe action figure ready for space flight, and one of the largest toys ever produced - an aircraft carrier model that's over 7 feet long. Kate appraises Allen's expansive collection and offers Allen the chance to trade one of his beloved items from his childhood for a rare item in mint condition. Also, emotions run high as Allen receives a sentimental message from one of his all-time heroes.

A quick look into Ronald Toby's home reveals a man with a passion for preserving history. While each room relays a special theme, from an African Safari to a 1940s-themed kitchen, our host, Lisa, narrows in on some of Ronald's favorite toy and sports collectibles. From an original Roy Rogers Quick Shooter Hat to boxing gloves signed by Muhammed Ali and Joe Frazier, Ronald has been holding on to many of his collectibles since his childhood. Our expert, Scott Ibarra, takes on the challenge of appraising Ronald's "blue collar museum" and taps into Ronald's nostalgic heart when he offers to trade an item for a toy that transports Ronald back to his childhood.

Stewart Berkowitz's passion for the TV shows he grew up with has evolved into a collection like no other. Gilligan's shirt, Fonzie's jacket, and Jeannie's harem costume figure prominently in this Classic TV prop collection. Stewart's favorite comedian, Jackie Gleason, and his comedy classic, The Honeymooners may be the capstone in this finely curated, museum-like collection. Our expert and certified appraiser, Judy Martin is tasked with putting a value on this colossal collection. Then, she will try trading a special classic TV prop she brought in exchange for one of Stewart's classic TV costumes.

As a kid, Stefan remembers being terrified of the fan in "Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory, which later turned into an insatiable obsession with fans and all sorts other antique electrical appliances. An antique store owner, he sells many of these items but has amassed an amazing electrical collection of his own, which includes the very rare Tesla fan motor, an old chamber stove, and of course, antique fans. Judy Martin, a certified appraiser, who knows a thing or two about some of Stefan's items and will try to put a dollar amount on his vast collection. She also hopes to make a trade with Stefan--one of his antiques, for something she thinks will be calling out for him.

Lisa steps into Allen Machielson's "Whoseum" and is transported through time and space to view an impressive collection of Dr. Who memorabilia. From custom-built replicas of the TARDIS and TARDIS consoles to prototype toys, Allen's beautifully displayed collection captures the growth of his passion for the longest-running sci-fi series. Allen's companion, his wife, Chrissy, has developed an appreciation for Dr. Who over the years, but her appreciation may grow when she hears our expert's appraisal. Movie props and costume expert Mark Short began his own collection of screen-used props and costumes with Dr. Who memorabilia, so he's primed with a perfect trade item to entice our collector.

Mike Haviland is the man of Mayberry with his impressive collection of The Andy Griffith Show memorabilia. From a replica 1964 patrol car to an autograph collection encompassing nearly the entire town of Mayberry, Mike's collection of nearly 2000 items spans multiple rooms of his home. In addition to his impressive collection, Mike's passion for the classic show has earned him the title of "Andy Griffith Show Trivia World Champion" - twice. Pop-culture historian Rob Klein appraises Mike's favorite pieces and also interjects his own personal stories from his childhood spent living across the street from Andy Griffith. Before Rob reveals a special trade opportunity, Lisa surprises Mike with a special message from someone close to classic TV's favorite sheriff.

Kenneth Ladd leads a magical life as the owner of a magic shop and museum with its very own theater where he performs as a magician. Joining Kenneth is his son Kevin, who helps collect and curate the magic memorabilia. Kenneth explains to Lisa how another illusion, the Sword Basket is done, but won't reveal the secret behind it. We've brought along our expert, Greg Abbott, a man whose magic company just so happens to have made the Sword Basket trick and other special magic items. Greg will appraise Kenneth's collection and then see if he can trade one of his magic tricks for one of Kenneth's prized possessions.

Vivian has been a fan of Wonder Woman ever since she was a little girl and began watching it on TV. Her Underoos, Mego dolls, comic books, and 1940's Wonder Woman Valentine's Day Card are just some of her favorite items.

Jack shares his knowledge, and favorite items from his Guinness-World-Record-holding Charlie's Angels collection, including a Charlie's Angels-themed van, modeled after a popular '70's toy kit.

Tom Pfrogner has outfitted his basement with a life-sized reproduction of the Jupiter Two Flight Deck and talking B9 Robot which accompanies his collection of screen-used and screen-worn props and costumes from the cult-classic TV show.

Patrick Brickley is a lifelong lover of film and television and he shares his favorite screen-used and screen-worn props and costumes, including items from Seinfeld, Good Will Hunting, Almost Famous, and Fast Times at Ridgemont High.